Transcript from closed hearing for alleged Charlie Kirk killer released

2 hours ago 15

A Utah justice connected Monday ordered the merchandise of a transcript from a closed-door hearing successful October implicit whether the antheral charged with killing Charlie Kirk indispensable beryllium shackled during tribunal proceedings.

State District Judge Tony Graf said nationalist transparency was "foundational" to the judicial strategy earlier ordering the merchandise of details from the Oct. 24 closed hearing. Attorneys for media outlets, including The Associated Press, had argued for entree due to the fact that they said it was besides the archetypal clip defence attorneys suggested a prohibition connected cameras successful the courtroom.

Prosecutors person charged Tyler Robinson with aggravated execution successful the Sept. 10 shooting of the blimpish activistic connected the Utah Valley University field successful Orem. They program to question the decease penalty. Robinson has not yet entered a plea.

In a 97-page transcript released aboriginal Monday, attorneys for Robinson argued that wide videos and photos of him shackled and successful jailhouse covering could make bias against him among imaginable jurors. Defense lawyer Richard Novak said prohibiting cameras would beryllium "very easy" for the tribunal to enforce and could assistance curb ocular prejudice.

"We're not litigating this lawsuit successful the press," Novak said during the Oct. 24 hearing.

The transcript contained constricted redactions to region discussions of information protocols successful the intimately watched case. Graf besides ordered the merchandise of an audio signaling of the hearing, again with redactions.

Robinson was not contiguous successful tribunal Monday and appeared via audio provender from the Utah County Jail.

Graf has not ruled connected the defense's proposition to prohibition cameras, but helium has implemented different limitations.

Days aft the closed-door hearing, Graf ruled that Robinson could deterioration civilian clothes successful pretrial hearings but indispensable besides deterioration restraints to guarantee the information of tribunal unit and Robinson himself. Utah tribunal rules necessitate defendants who are successful custody to beryllium restrained oregon supervised astatine each times unless different ordered.

Graf besides prohibited media outlets from publishing photos, videos and unrecorded broadcasts that amusement Robinson's restraints to assistance support his presumption of innocence earlier a trial.

The justice concisely stopped a media livestream of a proceeding earlier this period and ordered the camera beryllium moved aft Robinson's attorneys said the watercourse showed the defendant's shackles. Graf said helium would terminate aboriginal broadcasts if determination were further violations.

Lawyers for the media wrote successful caller filings that an unfastened tribunal "safeguards the integrity of the fact-finding process" portion fostering nationalist assurance successful judicial proceedings. Criminal cases successful the U.S. person agelong been unfastened to the public, which the attorneys argued is impervious that trials tin beryllium conducted reasonably without restricting reporters.

In a abstracted ruling Monday, Graf denied a petition from attorneys for the media who sought to intervene successful the case. The justice said members of the property bash not request to beryllium ceremonial parties successful the proceedings to entree tribunal records.

Still, Graf said the progressive publications indispensable beryllium notified of aboriginal requests to adjacent hearings oregon restrict entree to tribunal filings.

Prosecutors are expected to laic retired their lawsuit against Robinson astatine a preliminary proceeding scheduled to statesman May 18.