Mangione's attorneys discussed possible plea deal but talks fell apart, sources say

Defense attorneys for Luigi Mangione, facing charges successful the sidesplitting of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, and national prosecutors successful New York discussed a imaginable plea woody successful the lawsuit up of a proceeding Monday, but talks fell apart, according to 2 sources acquainted with the matter.  

It is unclear however adjacent the 2 sides came to a imaginable plea statement earlier negotiations ended, according to the sources. It is chartless whether determination volition beryllium an effort to resume discussions. 

The pretrial proceeding successful the lawsuit scheduled for Monday successful Manhattan national tribunal is inactive expected to instrumentality spot to sermon plans for an upcoming trial.

Mangione is facing some authorities and national charges for Thompson's execution successful December 2024. He has pleaded not blameworthy successful some cases.

A spokesperson for the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York declined to remark to CBS News connected the plea negotiations. CBS News has reached retired to Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg.  

NBC News New York archetypal reported Thursday that Mangione's attorneys had talks with national prosecutors astir a imaginable plea woody successful beforehand of the scheduled tribunal proceeding connected Monday, July 6, citing sources acquainted with the matter.

Mangione's attorneys had said successful a connection to CBS News earlier Thursday that the study was "troubling."

"This accusation attributed to 'anonymous sources' is portion of a troubling, deliberate signifier by prosecutors and instrumentality enforcement to prejudice Luigi, manipulate nationalist opinion, and interruption his law close to a just proceedings and impartial jury," defence lawyer Karen Friedman Agnifilo said. "Every suspect successful America is presumed guiltless until proven guilty, including Luigi, who has to combat the aforesaid charges twice."

Discussions betwixt prosecutors and defence attorneys anterior to trial, including discussions astir plea agreements, are common, ineligible experts told CBS News.

"They're going to person a speech astir whether oregon not they volition bash a deal. It is not astatine each uncommon to person a speech astir a imaginable plea woody passim the process," CBS News ineligible expert Jessica Levinson said.

"Generally, the defence volition say, 'Hey, tin we plead this out,' and prosecutors volition say, 'Here's what we tin offer,'" said erstwhile Palm Beach County State Attorney Dave Aronberg.

Plea agreements tin beryllium negotiated each the mode up until trial, arsenic successful the caller lawsuit of Bryan Kohberger, who pleaded guilty past July to the murders of 4 University of Idaho students arsenic portion of a plea woody that spared him from facing the decease penalty.

"To paraphrase Lenny Bruce, 'In the halls of justice, justness is often done successful the halls,'" Aronberg said.

Earlier this month, Mangione's attorneys said they mightiness question a psychiatric defence for Mangione successful his New York authorities trial. The pursuing day, connected June 18, Mangione's attorneys abruptly withdrew the notice of their intent to reason an "extreme affectional disturbance."

Mangione's lawsuit has garnered outsized attraction from astir the satellite since helium was accused of the December 2024 sidesplitting of Thompson extracurricular a healthcare manufacture league successful Midtown Manhattan. 

The proceedings successful the authorities lawsuit is acceptable to statesman successful September, followed by the federal interstate stalking trial scheduled to statesman successful November. 

Alice Gainer contributed to this report.

In:

• Luigi Mangione