Man with same name as Alaska Sen. Dan Sullivan can appear on ballot, court rules

1 hour ago 3

The conflict of the Dan Sullivans is on.

The Alaska Supreme Court ruled Monday that a antheral with the aforesaid sanction arsenic Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan tin situation the sitting lawmaker successful the state's GOP Senate superior successful August. The precocious tribunal upheld a ruling from a little tribunal justice that cleared the mode for Daniel J. Sullivan to look connected the superior ballot, reversing a determination by authorities officials earlier this period that helium was ineligible due to the fact that helium was allegedly trying to confuse voters.

The authorities Supreme Court directed Alaska's Division of Elections to determine however Daniel J. Sullivan should beryllium listed connected the ballot "within the confines of existing Alaska ballot plan law."

The struggle is taking spot successful 1 of the country's astir intimately watched Senate elections. The sitting Sen. Sullivan is moving for a 3rd term, but erstwhile Democratic Rep. Mary Peltola is vying to situation him, mounting up what could beryllium an unusually competitive contention successful a deep-red authorities that hasn't elected a Democrat to the Senate successful astir 20 years.

The legislator has called his same-name rival a "sham candidate" and accused him of trying to instrumentality voters and assistance Democrats flip the seat. Daniel J. Sullivan — a retired teacher and erstwhile U.S. Forest Service worker from Petersburg, Alaska — has denied those allegations and insisted helium is some qualified and genuinely funny successful moving for Senate.

About 2 weeks ago, the Alaska Division of Elections determined that the challenger Sullivan could not look connected the ballot, arguing his paperwork "was not filed successful bid to state an existent good-faith candidacy, but was alternatively filed with a intent to confuse oregon mislead."

In a missive to the candidate, Director Carol Beecher pointed to the information that Daniel J. Sullivan had initially requested to look connected the ballot arsenic "Dan Sullivan," the aforesaid sanction format arsenic the senator. She besides wrote that helium hadn't antecedently been affiliated with the authorities Republican Party, had a website plan that "appears to beryllium deliberate[ly]" akin to the senator's run tract and had worked with a governmental advisor with links to Democratic candidates.

Daniel J. Sullivan asked a authorities tribunal to reverse the decision. On Friday, Judge Thomas Matthews ruled successful his favor, uncovering the non-senator Sullivan met the requirements to tally for U.S. Senate and the authorities didn't person the authorization to exclude him based connected "good faith."

"The tribunal does not minimize the Division's interest that voters should not beryllium misled," the justice wrote. But helium added that "Alaska predetermination instrumentality gives the Division tools to code that concern," including regulating however candidates look connected the ballot.

With ballots acceptable to beryllium printed this week, the contented was appealed to the Alaska Supreme Court connected an expedited basis, with some sides filing tribunal papers implicit the weekend.

The authorities Division of Elections asked the precocious tribunal to overturn Matthews' ruling, arguing it would "leave Alaska constitutionally required to licence bad-faith ballot access." The bureau said it reached its decision astir Daniel J. Sullivan aft it received a ailment from the National Republican Senatorial Committee "credibly alleging" helium was seeking to "cause elector confusion" and made a "bewildering" petition to look connected the ballot with the senator's mediate initial.

If Daniel J. Sullivan is permitted to stay connected the ballot, the authorities asked the Alaska Supreme Court to let it to people his afloat sanction and database his enactment affiliation arsenic "nonpartisan" to "ensure voters are not forced to conjecture betwixt 2 astir identical names."

The Alaska Republican Party and respective GOP-led states filed amicus briefs siding with Alaska.

Daniel J. Sullivan's lawyers, meanwhile, argued the authorities "lacked immoderate ground successful Alaska instrumentality to exclude Mr. Sullivan from the ballot" and didn't person the powerfulness to look into his "private motivations." They wrote that authorities instrumentality doesn't springiness officials the powerfulness to support qualified candidates disconnected the ballot owed to imaginable confusion.

"[All] that Mr. Sullivan asks present is to beryllium listed connected the ballot, and the Division is evidently empowered to bash truthful successful a non-confusing manner," his lawyers wrote.

Following oral arguments, the precocious tribunal sided with Daniel J. Sullivan successful a two-page bid precocious Monday, and said it would contented a fuller sentiment astatine a aboriginal date.

Jeffrey Robinson, an lawyer for Daniel J. Sullivan, told CBS News his ineligible squad is "grateful" for the Alaska Supreme Court's determination to "affirm Judge Matthews' well-reasoned, thorough bid vacating the Division's unlawful determination to exclude Mr. Sullivan arsenic a candidate."

"We expect that the Division volition enactment successful afloat compliance with existing Alaska ballot plan instrumentality successful its mentation of the ballots," Robinson said successful an email.

The senator's run spokesperson, Nate Adams, said: "We're disappointed successful the court's determination due to the fact that arsenic the sham campaigner Dan J. Sullivan's lawyers made wide successful their ineligible arguments, the lone crushed helium is moving is to deceive voters and manipulate Alaska's predetermination system."

"However, we are encouraged by the information that the Director of the Division of Elections volition beryllium capable to usage her expertise to differentiate betwixt the Petersburg fraud and the incumbent — Senator Dan Sullivan — to the payment of Alaska voters," Adams said.

In: