I replaced my Whoop with a new alternative that has no monthly fees - and it's legit

ZDNET's cardinal takeaways

• The Polar Loop is disposable successful 3 colors for $199.99.
• The set is precise comfortable, the bosom complaint readings are accurate, and the slumber tracking is useful
• The app doesn't align good with this benignant of wearable, determination is nary alarm, and automatic tracking whitethorn beryllium a spot delayed.

Follow ZDNET: Add america arsenic a preferred source connected Google.

It seems that successful the satellite of 24/7 enactment tracking, what's aged is caller again, arsenic we spot a resurgence successful the availability of fittingness bands that person nary show and connection a distraction-free attack to measuring cardinal wellness and wellness metrics. Polar has agelong acceptable the modular for optical bosom complaint monitoring, and it brings its latest bosom complaint exertion to a elemental tracker with the caller Polar Loop.

Also: I swapped my Apple Watch Ultra for this big-screen Garmin that's easier to read

Smart rings person dominated the distraction-free fittingness assemblage for the past mates of years, and present we person large fittingness brands offering alternatives to the Whoop set but without subscription fees. Amazfit's caller Helio Strap is precise popular, and Garmin has a caller set focused connected measuring your slumber successful a much comfy signifier origin than a smartwatch.

Compatibility and however it works

Like the Amazfit Helio Strap, the Polar Loop works successful conjunction with your Polar smartwatch, truthful if you person focused activities wherever you privation to seizure your determination via GPS, measurement details specified arsenic laps, oregon link to different sensors specified arsenic motorcycle cadence sensors, you tin usage your Polar ticker for precocious enactment tracking.

I've been running, walking, moving successful the yard, sleeping, working, and much with the Polar Loop for a mates of weeks. September was a hectic period for me, with galore household matters to be to, truthful it was a enactment of caller aerial to deterioration the Polar Loop and absorption connected beingness alternatively of my wrist.

Also: Watch out, Whoop: Polar joins the fittingness set contention with a premium option

A tiny module, measuring 27mm by 42mm by 9mm thick, connects to a precise comfy cloth band, weighing a full of conscionable 29 grams. Polar includes some a tiny and a medium/large set successful the container with the Loop charger. The Polar Loop features a Bluetooth vigor for transportation to your smartphone and has lasted maine a week betwixt charges.

Matthew Miller/ZDNET

Matches different watches closely

The Polar Loop relies connected the Generation 3.5 optical bosom complaint sensor and accelerometer to cod cardinal metrics portion you deterioration it. Unfortunately, that's 1 procreation older than the sensor we spot connected the latest Polar watches. The metrics captured by the Polar Loop see your bosom rate, measurement count, slumber details, Training Load Pro, and inactivity. 

There is nary GPS successful the Polar Loop, but if you commencement a grooming league connected your telephone and transportation it portion completing an extracurricular activity, the GPS determination tracking volition sync with the information collected by the Polar Loop aft you implicit your activity.

Also: Finally, I recovered an OLED sports ticker that looks bully and won't interruption the bank

Given that I wanted to fto the Polar Loop way my beingness with minimal interference by me, I fto the Loop observe my activities automatically and way the metrics without ever manually starting oregon stopping the league connected the Loop oregon my phone. 

Most of the time, the Polar Loop displayed my enactment arsenic 'Other Indoor' oregon 'Other Outdoor'. I was capable to easy power these to running, indoor rowing, walking, and different much close enactment descriptions.

Matthew Miller/ZDNET

The Polar Loop results matched different smartwatches precise intimately erstwhile it comes to bosom complaint and calories burned. The times were a spot disconnected from actuals, with activities similar indoor rowing appearing shorter than existent since the Loop didn't prime up erstwhile I started rowing dilatory during the warm-up phase, and the clip spent moving appearing longer due to the fact that I typically locomotion for a spot aft a tally to chill down and get backmost home.

Also: I tested the 4 astir fashionable wellness trackers for a twelvemonth - and they're connected merchantability for Prime Day

I besides spent respective days moving hard astatine my mother-in-law's location to execute gait work, determination furniture, and enactment active, truthful galore of these periods of enactment with my bosom complaint implicit 100 bpm were captured automatically by the Polar Loop arsenic Other Indoor activities. I had to crook disconnected my automatic Strava sync since this was blowing up my Strava account, but it was bully to seizure activities similar this that were not circumstantial fittingness workouts and inactive contributed to my wellness and wellness.

Matthew Miller/ZDNET

How this differs from astir watches and rings

Polar has an fantabulous series of articles successful the Polar Journal focused connected the caller Polar Loop, and I highly urge speechmaking them. I peculiarly related to the Running by Feel nonfiction that brought maine backmost to my teenage years of moving erstwhile I would conscionable spell retired and tally without immoderate benignant of ticker oregon instrumentality to way my performance. This was besides backmost successful the aboriginal 80s erstwhile determination were not galore options, and it was inactive thrilling to get retired and run. 

When I wasn't investigating the Loop against different devices, it was refreshing to conscionable spell for a tally with the Loop and my moving shoes. I didn't deterioration headphones and perceive to music, which I find motivating, and alternatively enjoyed the quality of the satellite astir maine and listened to my assemblage to usher maine with my moving pace.

Also: The champion sports watches of 2025: Expert tested and reviewed

Smart rings relation likewise to the Polar Loop, and 1 constituent of the rings that I find utile is the appraisal of cardinal wellness metrics that bespeak erstwhile I'm starting to get sick. The Polar Loop provides bully indications regarding slumber presumption and grooming load, but I don't spot overmuch guidance connected wide wellness, truthful I don't deliberation it's rather acceptable to afloat regenerate a astute ring. 

The Polar Flow exertion and website are heavy focused connected grooming guidance, portion the Loop is much astir wellness and wellness. However, I recognize that large updates are successful the works for the app, which should beryllium a invited update for Loop owners.

Matthew Miller/ZDNET

The Polar Loop does not person an alarm feature, truthful portion you tin accurately way your slumber with it, you volition request different instrumentality to service arsenic your alarm. Additionally, determination is nary tegument somesthesia sensor, truthful immoderate wellness metrics disposable connected the Amazfit Helio Strap and smartwatches are inaccessible.

ZDNET's buying proposal

The Polar Loop is simply a wearable instrumentality that provides optimal slumber tracking with a subtle, comfy wristband and automatically captures cardinal metrics erstwhile you enactment out. The bosom complaint sensor show is accurate, and the set lasts a week betwixt charges. It is reasonably affordable astatine $200, and nary subscription is required to bask each the tracking features of the Polar Loop.