Defense team in Charlie Kirk murder case says courtroom cameras are unfairly tilting case

PROVO, Utah (AP) — Defense witnesses successful the prosecution of the antheral accused of sidesplitting Charlie Kirk said Friday that conjecture successful the media implicit his guilt and depictions of him arsenic a “monster” are making it intolerable for Tyler Robinson to get a just trial.

The pretrial grounds came arsenic Robinson’s attorneys pressed a Utah justice to prohibition cameras from his case. They said unrecorded broadcasts of the proceedings are tainting imaginable jurors, by feeding into speculative stories based connected Robinson's courtroom demeanor and alleged confessions.

Media organizations, prosecutors and Kirk’s widow, Erika Kirk, privation the tribunal to let cameras. They reason transparency is the champion mode to defender against the misinformation and conspiracy theories that interest Robinson’s defence team.

Robinson’s parents sat down him for Friday's proceeding successful a half-full courtroom. His begetter lowered his caput and stared down astatine his hands portion the defence played a Fox News clip successful which a commentator identified arsenic a erstwhile FBI cause opined that Robinson was a sociopath.

“It's turning extracurricular the courtroom into similar a world TV show,” said defence witnesser Bryan Edelman, a societal scientist with a California-based proceedings consulting business. “I deliberation it creates unit connected everybody to person cameras successful here, from the assemblage to everyone involved."

Prosecutors mean to question the decease punishment for Robinson if helium is convicted of aggravated execution successful the Sept. 10 shooting of Kirk. The blimpish activistic was addressing a assemblage of thousands connected the Utah Valley University field successful Orem erstwhile helium was changeable successful the neck.

Robinson, 23, turned himself successful a time aft the shooting and has not yet entered a plea. A proceedings day has not been set. Judge Tony Graf said helium would regularisation May 8 connected whether cameras volition proceed to beryllium allowed.

Cameras moved to the backmost of the room

Utah County authoritative Chad Grunander noted that astir each of the clips shown by the defence arsenic examples of media sensationalism did not see worldly from the courtroom livestream.

“Mischief lurks successful the acheronian oregon successful secret,” Grunander said. “Let’s radiance a airy connected these proceedings, a agleam light, truthful the nationalist tin person assurance successful what happens successful this courtroom.”

The sensationalism astir the lawsuit has chopped some ways. In a March 30 headline, the U.K.-based Daily Mail reported the slug that killed Kirk “did NOT match” a firearm allegedly utilized by Robinson. The communicative was based connected an inconclusive, preliminary uncovering by ballistics experts and led to speculation astir Robinson's imaginable exoneration. The FBI is moving further tests, according to tribunal documents.

Livestreaming by media outlets tested Judge Graf's patience during earlier hearings erstwhile excavation camera operators wrong the tribunal broke his rules.

During a December hearing, Graf temporarily stopped the livestream aft it showed the defendant’s shackles successful usurpation of a decorum order.

A January proceeding was interrupted erstwhile Robinson's attorneys said close-up shots of Robinson being livestreamed by a section tv presumption could again pb to claims based connected articulator reading. That, too, was a usurpation of Graf's order. The justice ordered the camera relation not to movie Robinson for the remainder of the hearing.

In caller hearings and again Friday, excavation cameras for the media were stationed astatine the rear of the courtroom, down Robinson. That sharply constricted opportunities to seizure video oregon photos of him successful court. Graf besides made camera operators travel earlier him to admit they understood the rules.

Mike Judd, a lawyer for a conjugation of media organizations including The Associated Press that are warring to sphere access, said Graf truthful acold has focused connected whether his rules wrong the courtroom are being followed, not what the media is saying extracurricular of court.

“The tribunal tin bash each of that successful bid to effort to power what gets fed into that media ecosystem,” Judd said. “You trim the likelihood of idiosyncratic publishing things that you deliberation whitethorn beryllium of perchance biasing interest aboriginal on.”

Policies connected cameras and livestreaming alteration among states. Cameras are mostly prohibited successful national courts.

“There's Supreme Court precedent that says courts mostly request to beryllium unfastened to the public, but that's not an implicit right,” University of Utah instrumentality prof Teneille Brown said. “Even if they let nationalist access, that does not adjacent a close to broadcast oregon record.”

Surveillance video and a handwritten confession

A preliminary proceeding scheduled for May volition let prosecutors to amusement they person capable grounds to proceed to trial. Authorities person said DNA accordant with Robinson’s was recovered connected the trigger of the rifle, the fired cartridge casing, 2 unfired cartridges and a towel utilized to wrapper the rifle.

But the defence argued Friday it cannot proceed with the proceeding until national instrumentality enforcement agencies crook implicit much details astir their DNA investigation of evidence.

Prosecutors responded that they person capable impervious beyond DNA to necktie Robinson to Kirk's killing. That includes surveillance video of Robinson adjacent the assemblage from the greeting of the shooting wearing the aforesaid apparel arsenic erstwhile helium turned himself in. Robinson near a handwritten enactment for his romanticist spouse confessing to the crime, and besides confessed to friends connected the chat country level Discord, prosecutors said.

“Justice delayed is justness denied,” Deputy Utah County Attorney Ryan McBride said.

___

Brown reported from Billings, Montana.

Copyright 2026 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.